By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Educate AIEducate AIEducate AI
0

No products in the cart.

Notification Show More
  • Home
  • Columnist
    ColumnistShow More
    The Fortune Cookie Folly
    February 3, 2026
    Education Leaders Must Look Ahead
    February 3, 2026
    Ready or Not: AI is Here to Stay
    August 27, 2025
    saying_goodbye_to_our_editor_in_chief_and_hello_to_our_new_managing_editor_featured
    Saying Goodbye to our Editor in Chief – and Hello to our New Managing Editor
    June 20, 2025
    Beware Artificial Teaching Assistants Bearing Gifts (Updated)
    June 20, 2025
  • K-12
    K-12Show More
    The Problem Isn’t Technology. It’s What We’re Training Children’s Brains to Do
    June 8, 2026
    From Content to Capacity: Rethinking Education for the Brain Economy
    April 24, 2026
    Turn and Face the Change
    April 2, 2026
    To Transform Learning, AI Must Start with District and Classroom Needs
    February 3, 2026
    Using AI to Foster Independence and Accountability in the K–12 Classroom
    August 27, 2025
  • Issues
    • Volume 2 Issue 4
    • Volume 2 Issue 3
    • Volume 2 Issue 2
    • Volume 2 Issue 1
    • Volume 1 Issue 6
    • Volume 1 Issue 5
    • Volume 1 Issue 4
    • Volume 1 Issue 3
    • Volume 1 Issue 2
    • Volume 1 Issue 1
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
  • About
  • Voices
  • Videos
  • Learning Futures
Reading: The Value of Struggle: Preserving Meaningful Learning in an AI Age
Share
Educate AIEducate AI
0
Search
  • Home
  • Columnist
  • K-12
  • Issues
    • Volume 2 Issue 4
    • Volume 2 Issue 3
    • Volume 2 Issue 2
    • Volume 2 Issue 1
    • Volume 1 Issue 6
    • Volume 1 Issue 5
    • Volume 1 Issue 4
    • Volume 1 Issue 3
    • Volume 1 Issue 2
    • Volume 1 Issue 1
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
  • About
  • Voices
  • Videos
  • Learning Futures
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
Educate AI > Articles > K-12 > The Value of Struggle: Preserving Meaningful Learning in an AI Age
K-12Professional Development

The Value of Struggle: Preserving Meaningful Learning in an AI Age

Marta Napiorkowska
Last updated: March 2, 2025 3:10 am
Marta Napiorkowska Published February 4, 2025
Share
SHARE

This article was initially published as “Gen-AI x Gen-Z/Alpha” by Nick Potalitsky in Educating AI. We thank Nick and the author, Marta Napiorkowska, for permission to republish it.

When AI arrived on the educational scene, I wasn’t entirely surprised. I had been teaching about the ramifications of developing AI for several years through a course called “Science in Literature,” which begins with neuroscience-based understandings of consciousness and then turns to tackling millennia-old questions such as “What does it mean to be a human being?” and “What makes human life valuable and good?” through literary texts. Increasingly in past years, our discussions in class had turned to machine-human hybrids (are we, as Elon Musk proposed many years ago, already cyborgs given our dependency on our cellphones and Google for memory and recall?) and synthetic life forms. As a result, ChatGPT’s powerful ability to imitate human language from behind the veil of a screen was discussed through the lenses of “the anthropomorphization of technologies,” not to mention the Turing Test.

However, I say, “I wasn’t entirely” surprised because my and my students’ experience of ChatGPT’s abilities continues to surprise me: it feels uncanny and sometimes even eerie. In philosophies of consciousness, the word for how experiences feel is “qualia,” a term coined by philosopher David Chalmers to refer to experience’s subjective quality. What it is like, or feels like, to experience the redness of red or the banananess of a banana is what “qualia” refers to. Enter the question of whether or not an artificial intelligence will ever develop consciousness, and we enter the world of deciding the degree to which we can have certainty that something has “qualia” or experience.

To test some of our hypotheses about the line between human and artificial consciousness, my students and I analyze Philip K. Dick’s Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, a 1968 science-fiction novel that we all agreed is beginning to feel more like science just around the corner. Famously, the novel blurs the line between humans and androids, using our uncertainty about genuine versus reported emotional and cognitive abilities, especially empathy, as its litmus test. If a person, or an android, reports experiencing care or behaves as if it cares, how can we be sure they aren’t just using words or mimicking caring behavior to fool us? How should we proceed if we can never be sure? We tested ChatGPT in various ways, and true to form, in various ways, it told us it wasn’t conscious. But its descriptions of itself invite cognitive creep: “At this point, I must pause and address a meta-philosophical question that arises while writing this paper: am I, the writer, an android?… I do not act based on predetermined programming designed to mimic autonomous decision-making. Like this essay, my responses emerge from collaborative interactions, drawing on vast knowledge. (emphasis mine).”

Knowing that our next reading would be Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, I sandwiched a particularly challenging paper prompt on Dick’s novel between the two. This year, I added a layer: I wanted to compare my students’ “qualia” of facing challenges and difficulty while writing papers independently to their “qualia” of using ChatGPT to do so. Part of the assignment asked them to reflect on and put into words their experience so that when they considered whether a world in which humans are biologically and socially engineered to “love what they have to do” and be “happy” is preferable to the one in which they live, they would have a recent lived experience of freedom combined with difficulty to compare it to. In the back of my mind was recent research on the neurochemistry of happiness, such as the release of dopamine upon achieving a goal, and positive psychology, which argues that a meaningful life is happier than a pleasure-filled one.

The prompt gave them six topics, some of which included several related questions. “Should androids have moral value? And if so, on what grounds does their value rest? If not, why not? Should they be as or more valuable than animals?” is one example. The prompt asked them to write a 3-5 page essay on their own first, submit it, and then introduce the same prompt to ChatGPT and write the same essay using it. They could prompt GPT further as much as they wanted, but doing so was not an explicit requirement, as I wanted to see what sort of engagement GPT inspired on its own and didn’t want to force students into any patterns, hoping that their experiences would be more authentic as a result. Then, they were to submit their AI-generated essay. Third, they were to reflect and report on their “qualia” while preparing both papers. Finally, the prompt asked them to prove they weren’t androids if they wanted to be in the running for an “A.” Doing so would show me they deeply understood our conversations and the novel. Here is a link to the entire prompt.

This last twist proved the most challenging and induced the most damaging “qualia” because the novel convincingly deconstructed the difference between androids and humans. None of the students believed they were androids, of course, but they couldn’t figure out how to prove it, and being unable to come up with an approach to do so quickly threw a few into an emotional frenzy. They barraged me with questions and accused me of unfairness, the answers being subjective. They claimed the task was impossible. Two approached their class Dean to complain and wrote a scathing email about me to the Assistant Head of School. Their trust, according to the AHoS, was “low.” Some who externalized their negative emotions also sought peer validation in group chats. One student later wrote, “I could sense others’ frustrations over texts and in conversations… many of us felt this was the hardest essay prompt we had been assigned during high school.” Through social contagion, a parallel to the novel’s empathy box, some adverse reactions even brought calmer peers down, as I later learned when a couple of students reported being so “stressed out” by these group texts that they had to disengage to get their work done.

However, not everyone reacted so negatively, and it didn’t matter whether they were academic highflyers or not. One student later wrote that he “at first experienced feelings of confusion” but was “overwhelmed with determination and even excitement to write on such an interesting and open-ended prompt.” Another wrote, “I felt excited about tackling the challenge.” A third: “I became interested in the idea of how one could weave a clever argument into a traditional essay to prove they are human.” One young man, a successful athlete whose rigorous training has inculcated resilience and confidence, calmly figured out an approach to proving he is a human within the first ten minutes. Unfortunately, he started asking me if his approach was right, and to avoid giving the whole game away, I had to stop answering questions in class so that others could come up with their approaches.

And they all did. Even those who initially reacted most negatively to difficulty testified to the meaningful, positive learning they experienced upon completing the project. One wrote, “My initial feelings of confusion and upset turned into inspiration… my essay turned into something I am proud of.” Another concluded, “I felt much more accomplished when I finished my own personal one.” Still another: “I felt a sense of pride…”

By contrast, their “qualia” of GPT’s essay was vastly different: “I didn’t find using ChatGPT to mean much of anything at all,” one wrote. Another believed that reading GPT’s essay wasn’t interesting, and none felt emotionally attached to its results. Only a couple tried to prompt GPT further to generate a better essay, but they didn’t experience the subsequent versions as being more important to them. Those who didn’t continue prompting did not explain why, but perhaps their disinterest shows, once again, some lack of care for a GPT response.

Some students’ final reflections also testified to the power and importance not only of authentic effort and overcoming difficulty but also of learning to trust oneself in the face of it: “After completing the entirety of the essay, my perception of self was a high-level thinker and intellect along with a determined student—a big difference from my perception of self after finishing the ChatGPT version.” Another wrote, “The trial and error, the challenge… this essay showed me what it is like to fail and work through my failures… Thank you for creating such an interesting prompt.” A third: “I experienced intense self-awareness and emotional involvement while writing the paper, which required all my focus. I found meaning in the original piece because I could sense the stress and fulfillment when wrestling with the prompt.” Another young woman wrote, “I proved to myself that I could work through a challenging assignment during a stressful, busy week.” Another compared his initial insecurity about the prompt to his final state by claiming straight-forwardly, “I became more confident.”

These self-reported descriptors—pride, satisfaction, meaningfulness, confidence—are all associated with increases in neurotransmitters such as dopamine, oxytocin, and serotonin. Or, in terms of positive psychology, the different sorts of happiness states that contribute more to life satisfaction than pleasures or feeling good ever can. Moreover, when working together on the projects, students also developed the single thing that contributes most to human happiness, according to the Harvard Study of Adult Development: positive, authentic relationships with other people, the very thing a person cannot have with an AI that lacks “qualia,” no matter how well it mimics internal states. By working together to overcome a challenge, students deepened their bonds.

It is already well known that difficulty and effort improve learning and that generating answers in one’s language helps to apply learning, such as theoretical ideas, to real-world life. As the many studies reported in Brown et al.’s Make It Stick make clear, struggle during learning isn’t detrimental but rather foundational. It is a sign that learning is happening, even if—and this is key—the learners themselves often experience less confidence while making the effort. As it turns out, effortful work and challenging tasks stress the brain enough to make the information a student is trying to learn more “sticky,” improving recall and learning. So, removing the difficulty and making things easier effectively reduces students’ learning.

While it may be possible to design a task that makes students put more effort into using GPT, such as prompting it to create increasingly better versions of its initial essay, doing so still puts students in the position of editors, working with material ready-made for them, rather than of generative creators, doing the hard mental work of reasoning and imagining what isn’t yet there on the page and then putting into their own words in a way others can understand. My students’ reported experiences also suggest that removing this sort of effortful difficulty—the kind of work that generative AI, in particular, takes away—reduces students’ understanding of absorption, satisfaction, pride, and meaning. In other words, generative AI takes away the experiences associated with neurotransmitters such as dopamine, oxytocin, and serotonin, generating feelings that lead to well-being, positive self-regard, and confidence. Is it possible, therefore, that despite our best intentions in encouraging them to use generative AI as a tool or tutor, we may be inadvertently contributing to the mental health crisis our students are currently experiencing? Is it possible we are taking away their ability to reinforce neural pathways of intellectual resilience, creativity, and grit to prepare our students for an AI-infused future? And interfering with their brains’ pathways enough to inhibit positive “qualia” of their lives? And thus, with their life satisfaction?

Like all of us, students are natural pleasure seekers. Unlike adults, however, middle and high school students often lack the executive function skills to think long-term about the impacts of their choices. Combined with the pressures of grades and college admissions (consider Jennifer Breheny Wallace’s excellent book Never Enough for a sobering picture of achievement culture), temptations to make things faster and easier are powerful. Given how quickly students reach for tools that will ease their effort, both in and outside of class, and how much earlier students will begin using them in their educational journeys, I’m confident that generative AI use will increase.

With an academic’s critical distance, I can support using generative AI and promoting its literacy. Difficulty is part of human life. Since society is filled with unpleasant surprises and human foibles, young people will always find challenges, exert effort, and overcome them, feeling all the positive feelings of accomplishment. So, will subsequent generations seek and find meaning elsewhere than in academics? In climbing a mountain or beating a cancer diagnosis? Probably.

But suppose we don’t make learning and pursuing knowledge feel meaningful and rewarding. In that case, we risk losing the value of both, and I don’t know any prosperous nation or civilization that doesn’t value knowledge, intellectual life, and inner virtues. The civilization in Brave New World has dispensed with all three in favor of entertainment, ease, and pleasure, effectively erasing the inhabitants’ desire for anything requiring any patience or inherent value, such as truth and beauty. Its citizens not only don’t want to overcome difficulty, they are incapable of doing so. Their very ability to make an effort has been nurtured out of them by their society.

Anecdotally, without an academic’s critical distance but with my past years as a comparison, I see students less intellectually resilient every year in my neck of the private school world, even among those who elect Honors courses. Fewer will Google words they don’t recognize; fewer can concentrate long enough to interpret a passage closely. More turn to study online “aides” to summarize their readings and to simplify the language, as well as the ideas, in their assignments. More of them want to take breaks or play games during class. More play games on their phones before school or during their free periods rather than use that time to study.

Meanwhile, teachers’ expertise is increasingly questioned by parents going “completely bonkers” to get their kids into college, as David Brooks recently reported in his article “How the Ivy League Broke America” for The Atlantic, and students respond to their parents’ pressures as well. So yes, I worry. I worry that we are inadvertently sowing not only the seeds of dependence on AI but also of generational existential crises. The lessons of Brave New World should remain with us so that we don’t accidentally create it on our own. My students already notice the connections between that novel and their recent writing experience, and I’m looking forward to reading what they have to say next.

About the author

Marta Napiorkowska is the English Department Chair at St. Luke’s School in CT. She earned her PhD in Comparative Literature from the University of Chicago, where she wrote on the philosophy, poetics, and cognitive phenomenology of sublime experiences. She has taught literature and interdisciplinary humanities for almost 20 years, 17 of which have been in independent schools, including St. Mark’s in TX and The Lawrenceville School in NJ. Her teaching and research interests focus on the intersections between literature, science, and philosophy. She wishes to thank all her students across 8 years of “Science in Literature” for their enriching contributions to her thinking.

You Might Also Like

The Problem Isn’t Technology. It’s What We’re Training Children’s Brains to Do

From Content to Capacity: Rethinking Education for the Brain Economy

Turn and Face the Change

To Transform Learning, AI Must Start with District and Classroom Needs

The New Foundations of Education: Cognitive Skills, Learning Capacity, and Wellbeing

TAGGED:QualiaStudent StruggleVolume 1 Issue 4
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow US

Find US on Social Medias
2.3kLike
5.6kFollow
1.7kFollow
3.4kFollow

Magazine Subscription

Subscribe to our magazine to get our newest issues instantly!

Popular

From Stanford University, Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence: How Harmful Are AI’s Biases on Diverse Student Populations?

Joel Backon Joel Backon October 30, 2024
Ethical AI: “The Alignment Issue” – Do Student Learning Goals and Ethics Align with AI
The New Foundations of Education: Cognitive Skills, Learning Capacity, and Wellbeing
Ethical Artificial Intelligence and The Immediate Needs Placed on Schools: Proactive Districts, Better Teaching, and Stronger Students
From Ethan Mollick, One Useful Thing: When you give a Claude a mouse

Categories

  • Advice
  • Columnist
  • Corporate Training
  • EdTech
  • Events
  • Higher Ed
  • IT
  • K-12
  • Profile
  • Reviews
  • Workforce Development

About US

Educate AI Magazine and media platform is designed to support those who want to enhance learning through AI. We serve K-12 school systems, higher education, corporate training, and learners everywhere.

Subscribe

Stay in the know on all that AI has to offer in the Education space.

SUBSCRIBE NOW!
2026 - © Educate AI. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?